Book Title: Pedro’s Journal: A Voyage with Christopher Columbus
Author(s): Pam Conrad
Illustrator/Photographer/Artist: Peter Koeppen
Publisher: Boyds Mills Press
Copyright Date: 1991
Genre: Historical fiction novel
Brief Annotation: Pedro’s Journal tells the story of Christopher Columbus from a unique perspective—through the journal entries and sketches of a young ship’s boy, who was invited on the journey because of his ability to read and write. Pedro writes of Columbus’ fiery temper, his insatiable greed, and his mistreatment of the natives in this account of the famous voyage across the Atlantic.
Your Rating (1-5) and why: 4—I liked Pedro’s Journal because I believe it will interest children in learning more about Columbus’ journeys. It also gives a more realistic perspective about Columbus and some of his exploits and cruelty towards the people he encounters in the new lands and towards sailors on his own ships, as well. I think this book will open up a lot of discussion and questions about ethics and exploration, especially during that era.
Readers who will like this book: Readers who like adventure stories; children who enjoy historical fiction; teachers who want to offer another perspective when teaching about Christopher Columbus and his “discovery of America”
Question to ask about this book before a read aloud: Who discovered America? Why do you think Columbus is said to have discovered America when people were already living here?
Optional, but noted as extra effort:
1. Interest Level (age): Grades 3—5
2. Grade Level Equivalent (grade): 5.5
3. List awards: None
4. Book trailer: None
Another book in keeping with your interest in multicultural, multiperspective books for kids. Have you read Encounter by Jane Yolen? If you haven't you should--you'd love it (text and illustrations complement each other beautifully), and you'd see a textset forming right before your eyes that focuses on seeing history from a more balanced and just perspective.
ReplyDeleteYour pre-reading questions will help kids get their heads around the important message in this book--just talking about what the word "discover" means is provocative. And be sure to include this word as the centerpiece of your word wall. That strategy is a great fit for this book, even for a whole unit on looking at history by reading stories of people whose stories aren't in mainstream textbooks. Another title I can recommend is York's Adventures with Lewis and Clark--we'll likely read this next fall in 7490, but you don't have to wait if you're intrigued ;-)