Book Title: Spuds
Author: Karen Hesse
Illustrator: Wendy Watson
Publisher: Scholastic Press
Copyright Date: 2008
Genre: Picturebook: Historical Fiction
Brief Annotation: Three young children, noticing how hard their single Ma works, set out on a cold night to try and help. They have a plan to harvest spuds, as many as they can carry, to feed the family. Things don’t go quite as planned and Ma’s reaction isn’t what they had hoped. But in the end, lessons are learned and love is shared… along with some potatoes.
Your Rating (1-5) and why: 3 – The theme and message of the story is nothing new. That, in and of itself, isn’t an issue – we can experience the same messages and themes over and over, and enjoy it, if the story is done well. Unfortunately, this story is not that interesting (or more so, it's not told in an interesting way). The upside, is this book uses language unique to it’s time period and could help facilitate a discussion about this time period, what these words mean, why we use different words today, etc.
Readers who will like this book: Young children who are able to begin learning about “messages” – you can talk about honesty, kindness, and charity.
Question to ask about this book before a read aloud: What are “spuds”? What does it mean when you say that someone had “good intentions”?
Interest Level (age): 5-8
Grade Level Equivalent (grade): 3.3
No comments:
Post a Comment